# EMD after TKA — all in-session calculations, reproducible in R # Wilson 95% CIs for failure proportions, risk differences (Wald), and # trial sample sizes. Sources: counts as reported in the abstracts (PMIDs noted). wilson <- function(k, n, z = qnorm(0.975)) { p <- k / n d <- 1 + z^2 / n c <- (p + z^2 / (2 * n)) / d h <- z * sqrt(p * (1 - p) / n + z^2 / (4 * n^2)) / d c(p = 100 * p, lo = 100 * (c - h), hi = 100 * (c + h)) } series <- data.frame( group = c("Primary repair","Primary repair","Primary repair", "Autograft", "Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft","Allograft", "Revision allograft","Revision allograft", "Mesh","Mesh","Mesh","Mesh","Mesh","Mesh","Mesh", "Mesh vs allograft","Mesh vs allograft","Mesh vs allograft","Mesh vs allograft", "Flap","Flap", "PJI+EMD","PJI+EMD"), study = c("Courtney 2018 repair arm, poor outcome (~33% of 58) [29248484]", "Dobbs 2005 complete QT repair, rerupture [15634812]", "Neitzke 2025 acute repair, reoperated [39384078]", "Rajgopal 2026 QT-bone block + ST [42088126]", "Leopold 1999 [10565649]","Burnett 2004 loose [15590855]","Burnett 2004 tight [15590855]", "Diaz-Ledezma 2014 [24462451]","Brown 2015 [25695977]","Ricciardi 2017 [27480825]", "Lim 2017 [28634096]","Baldini 2023 [36595053]","Salese 2026 [42127301]", "Weintraub 2023 [37003093]","Mao 2025 [40381965]", "Browne 2011 graft failure [21776550]","Abdel 2024 mesh failure [38194506]", "Abdel 2024 mesh revision [38194506]","Buller 2020 not functioning [32646680]", "Fuchs 2022 mesh revision [36132204]","Bateman 2019 [30964536]","Perry 2018 septic, mesh out [30180056]", "Anderson 2023 mesh failed [37001620]","Anderson 2023 allograft failed [37001620]", "Richardson 2024 mesh revised [37776982]","Richardson 2024 allograft revised [37776982]", "Russo 2023 not success [36752846]","Montoya 2026 composite failure [42036079]", "Anderson LA 2018 EMR failed [29439896]","Entezari 2024 triad AKA/fusion [38830429]"), k = c(19,4,17, 0, 7,7,0,11,19,8,5,8,5, 7,13, 3,28,17,14,3,1,3, 20,8,8,7, 4,11, 41,10), n = c(58,10,41, 29, 7,7,13,29,50,26,16,35,20, 10,17, 13,93,93,33,28,12,16, 41,15,30,20, 15,19, 53,22) ) ci <- t(mapply(wilson, series$k, series$n)) series <- cbind(series, round(ci, 1)) cat("== Failure proportions with Wilson 95% CI ==\n") print(series[, c("group","study","k","n","p","lo","hi")], row.names = FALSE, right = FALSE) # Risk differences (Wald), percentage points rd <- function(k1, n1, k2, n2) { p1 <- k1/n1; p2 <- k2/n2; d <- p1 - p2 se <- sqrt(p1*(1-p1)/n1 + p2*(1-p2)/n2) round(100 * c(rd = d, lo = d - qnorm(0.975)*se, hi = d + qnorm(0.975)*se), 1) } cat("\n== Risk differences (Wald 95% CI), percentage points ==\n") print(rbind( "Anderson 2023 failure, mesh - allograft" = rd(20,41, 8,15), "Richardson 2024 revision, mesh - allograft" = rd(8,30, 7,20), "Courtney 2018 poor outcome, repair - allograft" = rd(19,58, 30,68), "Baldini 2023 failure, septic - aseptic" = rd(5,13, 3,22) )) cat("\nBurnett 2004 loose vs tight: 7/7 vs 0/13 — RD = 100 points; Wald SE is 0 (degenerate). Exact test:\n") print(fisher.test(matrix(c(7,0,0,13), 2))) # Trial sample size: two-proportion, alpha 0.05 two-sided, power 0.80 cat("\n== Sample size per arm (two-proportion, alpha .05, power .80) ==\n") ss <- function(p1, p2, alpha = 0.05, power = 0.80) { za <- qnorm(1 - alpha/2); zb <- qnorm(power); pbar <- (p1 + p2)/2 ceiling(((za*sqrt(2*pbar*(1-pbar)) + zb*sqrt(p1*(1-p1) + p2*(1-p2)))^2) / (p1 - p2)^2) } cat("50% vs 35% (15-point difference):", ss(0.50, 0.35), "per arm\n") cat("50% vs 40% (10-point difference):", ss(0.50, 0.40), "per arm\n") cat("power.prop.test check (50 vs 35):", ceiling(power.prop.test(p1 = .50, p2 = .35, power = .80)$n), "per arm\n") ni <- function(p, margin, alpha = 0.05, power = 0.80) ceiling(2 * p * (1 - p) * ((qnorm(1 - alpha/2) + qnorm(power)) / margin)^2) cat("Non-inferiority, 10-point margin at 50% baseline:", ni(0.5, 0.10), "per arm\n") # Registry arithmetic cat("\n== Registry arithmetic ==\n") cat("Cases per 1,000 TKAs at 0.41%:", 1000 * 0.0041, "\n") cat("15 centers x 1,500 TKAs/yr x 0.41%:", round(15 * 1500 * 0.0041), "cases/yr\n") write.csv(series, "/home/claude/emr/build/emd_wilson_ci.csv", row.names = FALSE)